Montana
3 votes
Bush - 20 points
The last time this state voted Democratic....
... the Macarena dance was popular.
Race
- Overwhelmingly white
Nothing to report here.
Age
Seniors - Kerry
Everybody else - Bush
Strange dynamic here. Groups under sixty voted for Bush. Those
in the middle ranks heavily. Kerry actually won 51% of the senior
vote. Pattern looks much like a redder version of
New Mexico.
Economics
Poorest voters - Kerry
Everybody else - Bush
Kerry won a significant, though not commanding victory among
the poor. This would not be strange for the South but in the
Rockies, where economics often seemed to make less
difference, it was a bit unusual. The working class gave Bush a
small edge. The middle and working classes were a runaway for
the president.
Politics
- Average partisanship
- Significant Republican tilt
- Terrible Democratic loyalty
- Excellent Republican loyalty
- Independents split
This one is interesting. A seven-point advantage benefits the
Republicans here, but unlike many other heavily red states, that
advantage is not hopelessly large, nor is it backed by a big
"closet Republican" majority among independents, who split
right down the middle. The problem again was loyalty. The GOP
advantage became a washout due entirely due to defecting
Democrats. More than one of every five voted for Bush.
Meanwhile only one of every twenty Republicans abandoned him.
Of staunch red states, this one is intriguing and even hopeful. A
lower defection rate among Dems and a shift of the
independents would make it competitive.
New Hampshire
provides a successful example of how this can be accomplished.
Ideology
- Large conservative tilt
Cons outnumber libs by 2-1. But due to defection rates they
outvote them by even more. Interestingly, moderates are again
split.
Religion
- Protestant majority
- Sizable Catholic population
Both were unfriendly to Kerry, Protestants more so than
Catholics.
Demographics
- Heavily rural
- Sizable urban population
Some might be surprised that almost a quarter of Montana is
considered urban. More surprising is that they voted for Kerry by
14 points. But this was swamped by eastern parts of the state
combined with non-urban western areas. There are very few
suburbs.
Other factors
At 56% approval, Bush is more popular than his war, which
garners only 52%. Overall, despite a 20-point loss for Kerry,
there are signs of hope here.


The Land of the Blue
Where centrism and progressivism meet